Wednesday, June 9, 2021

Did Bhagwan Shri Krishna really said in bhagvadgita that womens are papyoni ? Fact check



jay Shri Krishna

Claim :-
 In bhagvadgita shri krishna said womens are sinner.

Fact :- 

Above claim has world's biggest Myth.

 Mostly the trend has been promoting that bhagwan shri krishna was said that womens are papyoni.

Mostly non Hindu's and Atheist are claiming that shri krishna said in bhagvadgita womens are papi .

They are showing bhagvadgita shlok 32 of chapter 9.

Let's check the shlok (Bhagvadgita 9:32)

मां हि पार्थ व्यपाश्रित्य येऽपि स्यु: पापयोनय: 

|स्त्रियो वैश्यास्तथा शूद्रास्तेऽपि यान्ति परां गतिम् || 9:32||

Meaning :-  O Arjuna! Women, Vaishyas, Shudras and sinners, whosoever they may be, by taking refuge in Me, they attain the supreme state.

Above translation from Gita press. And this translation is genuine. It's may be other versions of bhagvadgita are may be different from Gita press because of there own statement on the shloka. 

Now let's see ISKCON commentary on bhagvadgita 9:32

If whosever taking refuse in me surely they attain supreme state , no matter if they are sinners, womens, vaishyas, shudras. 

Let's see I showing you both Gitapress and Iskcon translation of bhagvadgita. Where they are showing womens are sinners?

They non Hindu's and Atheists are doing misconception of this Verse.

They are showing womens are sinner written in this shlok.

But the fact is shloka translation never says womens are sinner

Otherhand the shloka says vaishya, Sudra, Womens and sinners can also attain to supreme stage.

Here in this shloka did not say womens are sinners.  The shloka never says women and sinners are same.

If you read shloka carefully then you may see that papyoni and womens are different even you should read Sanskrit text only.

The sinners are different , womens are different, vaishya are different, Sudras are different.

We can conclude that 

- women is type of gender

-papyoni is the type of yoni

-vaishya and Sudras are type of varn.

It's a common sense that all types are different. Then how atheists and non Hindus are claiming that Womens are papyoni. All humans (men's and women's) are included in karmyoni.

Womens never include as papyoni.

Womens are different and papyoni different.

Papyoni includes Asur, rakshash, pret, bhoot, pishach, non-humans.  

Womens, men's I mean all humans are included in karmyoni not in papyoni, there is no matter that he/she is bramhan, kshatriya, vaishya, shudra. 

And last one Shri Krishna trying to say that asura ,bhoot, pret, pichach, non-humans who's including in papyoni also attain supreme stage.

Before blaming to our culture I advise to you please think logically.